When Happy was brought to the Florida petting zoo, there were 6 other elephants, each named after a dwarf in Snow White. Happy and another elephant from the seven, Grumpy, was brought to the Bronx Zoo. There, she and Grumpy lived with an older elephant, Tus. Eventually, the trio was moved to the “Wild Asia” section, where they met two new elephants, Patty and Maxine. However, due to old age, Tus died in 2002. Right after her death, Patty and Maxine attacked Grumpy, gravely injuring her. This caused Happy to be separated from her long-term friend Patty, who was with her for 30 years After the separation, a new female elephant companion was brought in to keep her company. However, she died a few years later.
To many animal rights activists, the action of separating Happy from her past companions was an act of cruel impediment. Happy was completely separated from Patty, while a fence kept her away from Maxine. Activists argued that the separation was cruel to Happy because she couldn’t be social with other elephants, as they are naturally social animals. However, zoo officials denied any fact that Happy was isolated, as they claim the elephants smelled and touched each other’s trunks. In 2020, the activists took the disapproval to another stage, as they filed a habeas corpus petition, which is a foundational legal mechanism that allows a detained individual to challenge the lawfulness of their confinement. However, the judge dismissed it.
