Book Review: Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder by Joanne Fluke
Joanne Fluke’s Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder is the first book of a mystery series with more than thirty books. With its comfy town setting, lovable characters, and delicious recipes, this novel makes an engaging read for mystery lovers.
Hannah Swensen, a smart, independent redheaded baker and amateur sleuth, who runs The Cookie Jar bakery, is realistically imperfect, and slightly stubborn. She lives in the town of Lake Eden, Minnesota where life is simple, sweet, slow-paced, and full of gossip. She’s not a detective but solves the mystery. Her friendly and outgoing attitude makes her reliable, and her match-making mother, creative coworker, and gossiping neighbors provide plenty of warmth and humor.
When Hannah stumbles upon a milk delivery man, dead as a doornail, she starts a murder investigation that reveals dark secrets hidden beneath Lake Eden’s pleasant surface. Using her wit, cookies and reputation of not gossiping, Hannah wheedles information from her neighbors to get clues, leading to yet another body. Hannah must find out who’s the murderer before they kill again. While the plot is a homicide mystery, its characters, their relationships, and the deep sense of community also play a large role. Her mother is on a mission to marry her off, her cat causes mischief, and her customers provide a great gossip source.
Joanne Fluke’s writing tone is light and humorous, focusing on community, family, and a touch of romance. The mystery has just enough red herrings and twists to keep readers reading. For example, Hannah saw a suspicious looking car below her apartment and thought it was the murderer to kill her because she was getting too close to the answer, but it was a neighbor’s mother visiting. The bonus of delicious recipes throughout the book offers a taste of Hannah’s baking, from ginger crisps to lemon tarts.
The pacing is relaxed, matching its cozy setting. The book doesn’t have much gore or blood, even though it is a murder mystery, making it kid friendly. It includes a couple recipes in almost every chapter, with precise measurements and pro tips from Hannah and her friends. The story is straightforward, making it a read for all-ages.
However, Hannah’s ability to conduct an unofficial murder investigation is partially unrealistic. The local police seem unusually welcoming to her involvement, and she is allowed access to information that probably should be restricted. Also, throughout the entire series, Hannah’s character shows shallow development; she remains in her 30s, and her love triangle drags across many books.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder is a delightful and satisfying beginning introduction to a series that has captured cozy mystery fans for decades. It’s perfect for readers who enjoy interesting murder mysteries and tempting treats. This novel combines mystery with warmth, focusing more on the relationships, routines, and life in a Minnesota town. The double homicide case and Hannah’s chocolate chip cookies make the book both a great read and delicious experience.